I discovered a disturbing court decision the other day. The 9th Circuit Court of Appeals decided that parents do not have an exclusive right to direct the education of their children. The ultimate authority, according to the panel of judges at the hearing, rests in the hands of the state government and the school districts. Now, this doesn’t sound that bad, really. But let’s look at the context in which this decision was made.
A group of Californian parents gave permission for their children to participate in a questionnaire that included, as the letter put it, questions that may make their children uncomfortable. The examples given in the letter were questions about experiencing violence or trauma. Ten of the fifty-something questions, however, were of a very sexual nature. When the parents discovered this, they sued the school district, claiming that they would not have given permission had they known that their children (ages 7-10) would be asked questions dealing with sexuality.
Now, in light of the case for which this decision was made, it has some interesting, and in my mind frightening, implications. According to this decision, parents do not have to be notified if their children are going to receive sex education. Also, parents do not have the right to have their children excused or withdrawn from such lessons. Now, I am not married, and I do not have children, but when I do, I want their instruction and education in this delicate subject to come from their mother and myself, not the schools. Public school “health classes” are far to problematic and, in my view, liberal. What right does the government have to take away my rights to be the only one to tell my children about the birds and the bees?
Not being satisfied with the article I originally found in the paper, I did a little research. What I found upheld my understanding of the court decision I got from the article. My research follows:
The official opinion:
US Court of Appeals of the Ninth Circuit
A news site:
Cybercast News Service
A Christian news site:
Crosswalk
Someone else’s personal opinion:
ChronWatch
(2-21-08) EDIT: I’m sorry, but these links are now broken. The pages they directed to have long since been moved or removed.